Tuesday, November 8, 2016

One War, Different Stories

The cover page of the magazine with black and withe photo of a skull-looking mask in the center. All words on the cover are written in French. On the very top, it says témoignages number 1 in white letters. Below that, it says Images Secrètes de la Guerre in Green. At the very bottom, it says 200 photographies censurées en France. As I was looking for materials for a session with the World War I history course, I found this serial publication in our Rare Book Collections. Témoignages de notre temps is a compilation of about 200 photographs taken during World War I which had been censured by the French government during the war. Produced by the "Société Anonyme les Illustrés Français," this is the first issue of the bi-monthly serial. The photographs have come from various entities in different countries across Europe, ranging from an archive to an individual who fought in the war. The preface notes that these photos were originally taken for the purpose of documenting the reality of the war. The anonymous editors urge the readers to see beyond the heroic and glorious image of war that the French government had publicized. According to the preface, one of the editors worked for the French government's censorship department during the war, which allowed a certain level of access to many of the censored photos and documents. However, in most cases, attempts to publish these materials were frustrated as the French government was still reluctant to make them available for public even after more than a decade.

The magazine is divided into different chapters which attempts to debunk myths on specific aspects of the war that the French government had created through its censorship. Though it would be great to take a look at them in this post, some of the photos were just too gory (for instance, a trench full of ripped apart cadavers) so I have intentionally excluded them from this post.

In the first chapter, the magazine dispels the myth that the French and German soldiers on the front held a deeply-rooted hatred towards one another. Like in these photos, French and German generals stand side by side to chill or visit an injured soldier together.

Black and white photo of three military commanders standing in front of a what appears to be a metal container with a cross sign on it. One on the very right is wearing a German military winter uniform and the one right beside in the center is wearing a French military trench coat. Another guy is standing on the very right side with a thick but light-colored winter coat with a hard hat.
Black and white photo of a military hospital with a man lying on a bed in the very front of the photo. Slightly right to the man are standing two military generals. One on the right is wearing a German military uniform and another one on the right is wearing a French military uniform with a cross symbol on his arm. Behind these three men are nurses and other patients going in and out of the room.

Though it was strictly forbidden for soldiers from the Allies and the Axis powers to force prisoner to contribute to their military efforts, it was not rare to spot German prisoners of war working in a French munition factory or vice versa.

Black and white photo of a brick-building factory with containers in front of it. In front of the container, one the right side stands a stack of cylinder shaped military munition. In front of the container and to the left of the stack stand six men wearing factory boots, thick winter jackets and berets.

Another type of frequently censored photograph were those of the soldiers from the French North African colonies. The French government did not want to give an impression that the African soldiers were part of the war efforts, especially on the front.

On the far left corner of the image is a small black and white photo of an African man standing in a winter military suit. He is holding a thick white stick in his right hand. The rest of the image is a black and white photo of a train. From one of the windows, an African man in French military suit is standing, putting his arm out to wave a white stick. He is wearing a turban.

The magazine continues to break down the binary of the devil German and the righteous Allies by showing more humane side of the enemies. Rather than being tortured by atrocious German prison keepers, the British prisoners of war play cricket in the German prison camp.

Black and white photo of a man in white polo shirt and black pants throwing a cricket ball while other players in white clothing stand to hit the ball. The cricket players are surrounded by men in various clothing, some wearing military uniform and others wearing suits.

African prisoners of the war casually cruise down the streets of Berlin.

Black and white photo of seven African men walking down a street. They are all wearing turbans and wearing a thick black winter fur coat. Behind them passes by a tram.

The wartime press coverage of Paris often times hid the ugly aspects of the reality to convince people that France was in good shape. But these photos tell the story of wartime Paris that the government strove to hide.

Parisians were not always as poised as the government portrayed them to be. They ransacked stores with foreign-sounding names, though most of them were businesses operated by French citizens.


Though the government would have hated to admit it, the Parisians also suffered from bomb strikes and shortage of food supplies.

Black and white photo of a cement brick building which has a big door with walls on its sides, which are lower than the door. Above the door is a some type of seal sculpted with cement. In front of the door is a big hole almost twice the size of the width of the door, around which cements, asphalts and metal debris are lying around. A ladder is inside the hole. Five male pedestrians, all wearing fedoras, are passing by the hole but no one is directly staring at it.

The rest of the chapters explain Axis propaganda; marine warfare (it was the first war that submarines were used for military purpose); and the arts of espionage.

Reading this serial publication made me wonder what was the contemporary public's reaction to these photos. Would they have been appalled that the government had been hiding some aspects of the war? Or maybe, it already was not so much of a "secret" despite the government's efforts to make them so.

To look at the publication yourself, ask for Rare Book D501 .T46 No. 1 1933:Mai in our reading room.

No comments :

Post a Comment